Pejman Fathi Strategy • Art • Insight
Pejman Fathi
Pejman Fathi Uncategorized

Why Customer Loyalty Programs Can Backfire

ژوئن 30, 2024

Introduction

Customer loyalty programs are ubiquitous, boasting over 3.3 billion members in the United States alone. These programs can provide retailers with a tremendous advantage: loyalty program members purchase more often from their affiliated retailer, visit websites and stores more frequently, and are more likely to download the retailer's app, follow them, and interact on social media. Furthermore, they recommend the retailer to family and friends.

The Downside of Loyalty Programs

However, new research conducted by professors at the Wharton School, in conjunction with customer experience consulting firm Verde Group, reveals a significant downside to loyalty programs. When loyal members encounter service failures—such as shipping problems, return issues, out-of-stock items, and the like—they become more upset than customers who are not program members. Because loyal members purchase more frequently than non-members, they encounter such issues more often. This problem was compounded by the surge in online shopping during the pandemic, meaning loyalty programs can actually inflict significant harm on retailers. The researchers have dubbed this the "Boomerang Effect," because the very loyalty the brand builds ends up harming it.

Key Findings

"This is a real problem for retailers," says Thomas Robertson, Academic Director of the Baker Retailing Center at Wharton and co-author of the study. "Businesses are inadvertently killing their golden geese."

The researchers surveyed over 5,000 U.S. retail consumers in February 2020 and another 2,500 in May, after the pandemic had taken hold. The results showed that loyalty program members not only experience more service friction than other shoppers, but they also expend significantly more effort to resolve their issues. For example, loyal members surveyed in May required an average of four contacts with the company before reaching a resolution, and the process took 5.1 days. Non-members required only 2.8 contacts and 3.3 days.

Paula Courtney, CEO of Verde Group and co-author of the study, notes, "These highly valuable customers are bouncing between different departments, expending effort to achieve resolution." Part of the problem is that members with a complaint often start by calling a dedicated number, only to find that the loyalty department cannot assist them. This is particularly damaging given that members have high expectations for how they should be served. Another issue is that members repeatedly have to ensure that the points or rewards they have earned are calculated correctly, which usually means they are routed back to the loyalty or marketing department.

Proposed Solutions

The researchers suggest three steps to mitigate the Boomerang Effect:

  1. Improve Staff Training: Employees across various departments must receive the necessary training to handle the problems of loyalty program members. This includes training in problem resolution and delivering superior service to loyal customers.
  2. System Integration: Retailers must integrate their systems so that different departments can access customer information and history. This allows customer issues to be resolved swiftly and seamlessly.
  3. Effective Customer Communication: Establishing effective and efficient communication channels with loyal customers can help alleviate their frustration. This includes providing direct contact numbers and robust online support.

Conclusion

Customer loyalty programs can be powerful tools for increasing sales and customer engagement. However, if not managed properly, they can backfire, causing frustration and dissatisfaction. By improving staff training, integrating systems, and establishing effective communication, retailers can prevent these issues and enhance the experience of their most loyal customers.

Uncategorized
Share: